Read the two expert responses to the topic.


Write a minimum 350-500-word response, in essay format, to the following questions:


o      Objectively summarize the view of each writer.  Be sure to state the writers’ names. Only summarize each writer’s view–do not include your own views or opinions about the topic or about the writers’ views.

o      How did each writer address arguments and counter-arguments?

o      How effective were the arguments presented by each writer?

·          What new information or insight into your topic did you gain? How does understanding the views of others help shape your own